What Inspires Donors to Give to Your Nonprofit?
Do you want to receive more donations for your nonprofit? Check out how you can provoke action instead of creating awareness.
Picture this: you just sent a mass email to your supporters asking for a donation. The email is professional. It’s full of useful statistics. It relies on accurate facts to make a strong argument.
Will it prompt your donors to open their wallets? Probably not.
Turns out, hard data won’t make people care about your cause. So, what inspires donors to support nonprofits? Spoiler: it isn’t professionalism, charts, or appeals to logic. In this article, we dive into the science of what makes people care about a philanthropic cause and commit to donating again and again.
Insights and Tips to Inspire Giving
Philanthropy is noble, but it’s anything but straightforward. Psychological studies indicate that people are motivated to support charities for a variety of complicated reasons, from a personal connection to a cause to how well the organization is able to craft its call to action. One thing is certain: when it comes to donations, emotions come first.
Drive Action, Not Awareness
This can’t be emphasized enough: People give with their hearts, not their heads. This means that all the most impressive, shocking, or accurate statistics in the world aren’t going to move people to make any behavioral changes. A few years ago, researchers in Stanford published a study that tried to persuade nonprofit organizations to “stop raising awareness already.” Why? Because it doesn’t work!
Awareness campaigns—which attempt to make people “aware” of a cause or problem with targeted messaging and communications—cost a lot of money and require a lot of labor resources but have been shown to result in zero behavioral change. At worst, they can result in a backlash or even cause harm. Simply put: when people are given information in the form of statistics, factoids, and graphs, they’re not only unlikely to change their beliefs or behavior, but they tend to hold on to their previous beliefs even more tightly.
So, what can you do instead? Instead of driving awareness, aim to drive change or action (for example, donating regularly or volunteering). To do that, an organization should try to appeal to people’s sense of identity. If a message runs counter to deeply held beliefs, it will be rejected outright. For example, if someone is skeptical that climate change is caused by humans, they won’t bother supporting your environmental organization because your messaging contradicts what they believe and how they see themselves.
Build An Emotional Connection
An effective way to connect with people without threatening their identities is to collaborate with community influencers who people trust. For instance, if you’re focused on conservation and a big chunk of the donors you want to target relies on spiritual leaders for information on climate change, then find ways to partner with those leaders, so that they become spokespeople for your cause. If you’re targeting young Gen Z supporters, tailor your messages to TikTok influencers whom young audiences already support.
The truth is, human beings didn’t evolve to donate impartially to philanthropic causes, no matter how noble or impactful those causes may be. Even when one charity is demonstrated to be more effective than another, donors still support the less-effective organization if they feel a personal, emotional connection to it.
Developing emotional connections based on trust is all about a strategic approach to communication that engages people’s values and identities, rather than threatening those identities with uncomfortable data or bombarding audiences with impressive stats. Remember: hearts over minds and action over awareness. Let that be a mantra!
Visual Language
Building on the previous insight about connecting with donors emotionally, communicate with donors by using visual language, especially when you’re writing that perfect donation letter. Successful nonprofits already know that imaginative, compelling images are key to any donor communication strategy, but translating visuals into language takes that tactic a critical step further.
Humans are visual creatures, with a third of our brains devoted to processing what we see. And the other two thirds? That’s mostly dedicated to the other senses. This means that if you’re trying to engage your donors by appealing to their reason, you’ll miss out on a lot of support. For supporters to really be moved by the language of your messages, they have to be engaged on a visceral level. Donors should feel like they can see, touch, smell, and hear the importance of your cause. Powerful language is visual language.
To make your messages more visually powerful, make use of figurative language. For example, saying “Susan is sad” evokes much less of a response than “Susan is drowning in a sea of grief.” While you don’t have to go overboard, injecting similes, metaphors, and personification into your messages will form a clear picture in the minds of your donors. Compare “The planet’s largest rainforest is under threat” to “The Amazon is on fire.” Which sentence sounds more urgent? The one that you can see.
Meaningful Calls to Action
Almost all nonprofits employ calls to action (CTAs) in their messaging. We’re perpetually asked to “Sign up” or “Click here to find out more” or “Donate now”. While CTAs like these can be effective and even necessary, they all have the same flaw: they’re generic. They express nothing unique or specific to the organization and you can find the exact same CTA on every other nonprofit’s page.
A motivating and inspiring CTA follows 3 rules:
- It’s specific.
- It indicates how to solve a problem.
- It’s something a donor understands how to do and can easily imagine doing.
If we continue with our rainforest example, a generic CTA might be, “Help save the Amazon”. That’s very general and abstract—it doesn’t give the donor any idea of how they can help the rainforest or how their donation accomplishes that. Not to mention, it has no visual components to help the donor visualize what they’re being asked to do.
A specific and meaningful CTA that’s easy to envision might say, “Plant 10 trees to restore habitats in the Amazon.” Whether you’re polishing up your nonprofit’s website or crafting a campaign message, aim to create CTAs that advance concrete goals that show donors exactly how their action will make a difference.
Emotions, Visuals, and Meaning
By forging emotional connections and employing visual language with meaningful CTAs that focus on concrete actions instead of just awareness, your organization stands a much better chance of inspiring donors to give more funds, more frequently. It’s all about relationships and trust. Generosity comes from the heart, after all.
FAQ
What Motivates Donors to Support Nonprofits?
Donors are often motivated by a personal connection to the cause and the desire to make a positive impact.
How Important is Transparency to Donors?
Transparency about how funds are used is crucial in gaining and maintaining donor trust.
Does Storytelling Influence Donor Decisions?
Effective storytelling can emotionally connect donors to the cause and inspire generosity.
What Role Does Donor Recognition Play?
Recognizing donors can make them feel valued and encourage continued support.
How Does Effective Communication Affect Donor Giving?
Regular, clear communication keeps donors informed and engaged with the nonprofit’s work.
Do Donors Respond to Urgency?
Creating a sense of urgency can motivate donors to act quickly.
How Can Nonprofits Demonstrate Impact to Donors?
Showcasing tangible results and success stories demonstrates the impact of donations.
What Influence Do Peer Recommendations Have on Donors?
Recommendations from peers can significantly influence a person’s decision to donate.
How Do Tax Benefits Affect Donor Decisions?
While not the primary motivator, tax deductions can be an added incentive for donors.
Can Social Media Campaigns Inspire Donors?
Well-crafted social media campaigns can increase visibility and inspire donations.
Does the Size of a Nonprofit Influence Donor Giving?
Some donors prefer supporting smaller nonprofits for a more direct impact, while others trust larger, well-established organizations.
How Do Nonprofits’ Goals and Vision Attract Donors?
A clear, compelling vision can align with donors’ values and inspire them to contribute.
What Impact Does Community Involvement Have on Donations?
Active community involvement can increase local support and donor trust.
Can Matching Gifts Programs Encourage Donations?
Matching gifts programs can motivate donors by doubling their impact.
How Important is a Nonprofit’s Website in Attracting Donors?
A professional and informative website is crucial for attracting and retaining donors.
Do Volunteer Opportunities Increase Donations?
Offering volunteer opportunities can engage individuals more deeply, leading to donations.
How Does a Nonprofit’s Reputation Affect Donor Decisions?
A strong, positive reputation can significantly influence donor confidence and willingness to give.
Can Special Events Increase Donor Engagement and Giving?
Hosting special events can raise awareness and funds, while directly engaging donors.
What Role Does Personal Solicitation Play in Donor Giving?
Personalized approaches can be very effective, especially for major donations.
How Do Newsletters and Regular Updates Influence Donors?
Regular updates keep donors informed and connected to the nonprofit’s ongoing activities.
Improve your Marketing with the Power of AI
See how you can start with AI Marketing and reach your goals faster than ever before. Check out the Tips, Strategies, AI Tools, Masterclass, Courses, and Community. Unleash the true potential of your brand with the help of AI.